Thailand’s most organized criminals are police

chai-rachawat.jpg

According to the United Nations, the Royal Thai Police are organized criminals.

That, at least, is the inference to be drawn from looking at its Convention against Transnational Organized Crime, which was adopted in 2001 and which defines an organized crime group as involving at least three people acting in concert over a period of time “with the aim of committing one or more serious crimes or offences… in order to obtain… a financial or other material benefit.”

It would be hard to overstate the extent to which Thailand’s police fit this definition. A browse through a few newspapers of recent weeks alone reveals as much.

In February there was the case of the border patrol unit that abducted and tortured people to extract money and force them to confess to narcotics charges. So far over 100 complaints have been lodged against it, the majority from persons serving jail terms, and also one policeman. Although the low-ranking officers involved have surrendered, investigators have reportedly said that there is no evidence to link their wrongdoing to their superiors.

Then was the car scam, which came unstuck when a victim of theft went to police headquarters to file a complaint and found his vehicle sitting in the parking lot: not impounded, being used by personnel.

The police had colluded with rental companies to steal perhaps over 1,000 new automobiles by fraud. So far, only a few of the cars have been recovered. Many will have been sold into Cambodia and Burma. The operation apparently stretched over a wide area and involved police from various units, including Special Branch and cyber crime. Senior officers have already sought to exonerate some, saying that they will face only internal, not criminal, inquiries. The hire company directors have been arrested.

Similarly, 21 police forensics staff accused of taking money for the cost of formalin that was never administered have been let off the hook and three civilian employees blamed in their stead. Joking about this case, cartoonist Chai Rachawat wrote in the Thai Rath newspaper that it is anyhow better for police to steal from the dead than from the living: his picture (above) depicts skeletons standing in coffins and yelling as a policeman makes off with the loot.

Aside from these incidents, police have been implicated in a number of recent killings: some execution-style, another in which a leading forensic scientist has said that their account of what happened does not match the evidence. Torture and other abuses meanwhile go on as normal.

Thailand’s police did not become an organized crime gang by accident. The modern force was from the beginning intended both as a criminal and political agency, monopolizing the drug trade and murdering or detaining opponents, including other police. It quickly became unstoppable as, historian Thak Chaloemtiara notes, while people whispered about its crimes “investigation was impossible, for the crimes were committed by the police themselves.”

Its heyday as an unsurpassed crime venture may have been in the 1950s, but until now the police force remains beyond the law and answerable unto itself. The institutional features of its criminality, including the routine use of force and self-financing of individual officers and stations, speak to how incidents of the sort described above are organized, not haphazard.

These conditions present persons interested in improving the work of the police with profound and peculiar difficulties. For some three decades there has been talk of reform, and a few attempts, including one by the interim prime minister of the recent military government. But all have failed, in the same way that attempts to turn any other organized crime group into a legitimate enterprise against the will of its members could not possibly do otherwise.

But had any attempts at reforming the Royal Thai Police succeeded, would it really have made any difference? Wouldn’t a reformed organized crime group remain what it is at its roots? How different are reformed organized criminals from their unreformed counterparts?

These questions could be cause for despair. After all, if things are that bad, then why bother? There are indeed many who think in this way, and do not believe that the police in Thailand can ever be significantly changed. Unsurprisingly, when this sort of thinking becomes widespread, it guarantees that things go on as usual. Without hope that anything can be done about the police, nothing can.

On the other hand, pretending that things aren’t as bad as they really are also ensures that things go on as usual. It allows people to fool themselves into thinking that a few quick fixes, like decentralizing and better training, may result in improvements. Superficially, they might. But anybody who looks honestly and seriously at the work of the police in Thailand for long enough will be obliged to acknowledge that it will take much more than this.

That’s why the U.N. definition is helpful. Let’s be honest and describe Thailand’s police as they are: organized criminals in uniform. If this much can be admitted, then it might be possible to get down to the business of what to do about them.

Source: Thai police are best organized criminals

Advertisements

8 responses to “Thailand’s most organized criminals are police

  1. Pingback: Surprise! The Police Might Be A “Gang” « deathpower

  2. Pingback: Asia needs a new rule-of-law debate - TeakDoor.com - The Thailand Forum

  3. some guy who does not want to be killed

    what you hear about do nothing to compare to the reality, murder and drug sales are the small parts. everyone knows about the slave trade, but here is the bad parts, one of the assistants to the queen is an open pedophile who freely supplies porn to any one whom wishs, the police in pataya torture, rape and then kill women who refuse to pay fines to them, in bangkok there are auction houses for slaves that are, although not directly run by the police, are perfectly aware of and bribed on a regular basis. children are kidnappered from school and the police do nothing to stop it because they are bribed and worst of all and worst of all you have the whole delima wityh the thaksin family distracting away from the fact that at this moment thousands are being killed in the south from “insurgents”.

    blessing all to the king, he has done alot for his country, but the country needs alot more help

  4. I hope a truly independent committee is set up and actually manages to complete its task of finding out the true facts about what happened on the crackdown of 7 October 2008 which affected a surprisingly large number of civilians:

    – 2 dead
    – more than 450 injured
    – several lost limbs, arm, foot, hand, eyes, fingers, toes
    – Death toll could rise as there are still the wounded in ICUs.

    The number of injured police officers stand at around 20 officers, one stabbed and some with gunshot wounds.

    Given the track record of the police, I think the findings would be yet another classic example of the police acting as criminals, at least those at senior levels who made the decision to bring in the brutal border patrol police and equip them with dangerous equipment (low quality chinese-made explosive tear gas).

    Of course, those on the side of the protesters who broke the law are also criminals (the few who fired guns and hit policemen with flagpoles, etc).

    Perhaps 7 October’s clash between PAD and Police can be described as a gang war…. Thailand’s most organised mob Vs. Thailand’s most organised criminals!

  5. I know full well how criminally minded the police in Thailand are. I work for a charity in pattaya, and recently had three children come to us compaining that they had been arrested for drugs, and then forced to make false allegations about several foreigners for supposed sex crimes, even though the boys protested they had never done such things. Six foreigners were arrested, even though two of these passports showed they were not in the country at the time of the alleged offences. All had huge demands of money made from the police to drop the charges. I have supplied the boys statements to one of the accused, who wishes to sue the police for fabrication of evidence and reporting a crime they know never happened, but he cannot find a single lawyer to take the case up, as they are all scared of being killed by the police. he has been warned that if he tries to pursue the matter he will probably be killed too. What a disgrace?
    Unfortunately the majority of visitors to Thailand have no idea how completely corrupt the police are, and how much danger they are walking in to when they enter. Embassies around the world should advise their citizens NEVER to come here. Perhaps utter destruction of the vital tourist industry will force the government to do something radical to rein these despicable criminals in. They are supposed to uphold the law, and are brutal to those they arrest, but are far worse than the majority of those they arrest.
    All the time investigations of wrongdoing by the police are investigated by the police, there is no hope of any sense of justice in the country ever being seen.

  6. wow, it’s really horrible what’s going on in Thailand. I always knew that it is bad, but I didn’t think it is that bad. What is even worse is that nobody seems to be able to really change anything.

  7. Hi I have a situation where after a simple motor accident that happened in Khon Kean that has now turned into a fabrication of evidence By a Thai policeman to extort money from a me UK tourist, and Thai motor Insurance.
    who do i go to, do i just stay way from Thailand now and let him have his way. Any help please

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s